Spenny : Coursework chaos?
Before we go on, it must be said that I didn't cheat per se, more like my school cheated. But therein lies the fault of the system. Schools are pressurised for results. If 99% of students don't get A*+ in every exam, the school is closed down and stripped for parts, the students sold for slave labour and every other teacher must donate a kidney to pay off the debt (or something like that). So what do schools do? Unable to boost the exam grades any further than making the exams easier (which benefits everyone but the students), they turn to 'helping' students with their independent coursework. Every science class we were in gave model answers for all our coursework needs, our maths teacher left a copy of the markscheme lying about and our English teacher gave such good notes that when strung together with a few conjuctives gave me several A*++ essays. Perhaps telling is the fact that the two essays for which we were left to fend for ourselves, I managed a low B in - something I am still unjustifiably proud of right now.
And ours was a good school. I know of some schools that refused to help in this way, with predictable results and an ever increasing circle of failure as funds were denied; and some that went even further, providing them with study guide books and telling students where certain websites were that 'helped' for a small fee. Because that was the price we paid for coursework. What was passable as an A-grade essay in an exam would be placed in the reject pile in coursework. You either made an essay worthy of Shakespeare, or you fell by the wayside and settled for your 29/30 (which was most probably a D).
And so steps in our current government. Firstly they have banned maths coursework, which involves far too much English to warrant the subject, and have now placed coursework under 'supervision' with time restraints. Surely this is just an extra long boring exam? How does this benefit those who don't thrive in an exam environment? Did they think through the extra time and effort needed by overstretched schools to implement this? I think not. This will, I can safely assume, impact on teaching for the exams (or push them back to the joy of students), which means further reductions in grades. And annotated texts were banned in exams only last year, something which were more than a crutch in my exams.
So, when next year's results are published with predictably high pass rates, don't moan that exams are getting easier. Because without any oppurtunities to cheat in skillful ways like we did, GCSE and A level students are thrown in at the deep end with 100% exams (essentially) without any help or resources. The 20 year experiment is over. Coursework is dead. Long live exams...
Britain_, Misc_, Spen_, etc_, ...








4 Comments:
I think the supervised coursework will end up a lot like my A2 history project that wasn't officially called coursework because we weren't allowed more than two coursework modules out of 6. Anyway basically we wrote it out in class and at home and then memorised it (I recorded myself saying it on a tape :P) and then we were allowed to take a page of notes and write the 4500 word essay out in timed conditions, handing it in notes and all for moderation. Weird and a real. Glad I've done GCSEs.
The danger of having no coursework, particularly at A level, is that many students will arive at university without having written an essay longer than 1000 words.
Apart from subjects like English or History, or any of the more obvious arts, a lot of coursework is only semi-essay based. The first GCSE coursework was geography fieldwork which was entirely analysis of data, and then a conclusion; there was no essay per se.
Biology is the only science I came across where an essay was written, and that was barely 1000 words.
Those going into medecine, maths, business or anything else non-arts tend to be already lacking in essay writing skills. I only kept mine up by doing economics where weekly essays were the norm (but interestingly had NO coursework).
Yes, obviously, but for science-based students essay-writing is not so important. I was talking about the merit of coursework in subjects such as English and history.
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home